The Contextual Controversy around the Ten Commandments as Moral Guidelines, or a Test?

Are you ready to confront the controversy surrounding the Ten Commandments head-on and dig deep into their potential role in your daily life? That's exactly what I'm doing in this riveting episode. I'm not just reciting the commandments; I'm exploring them through a fresh lens. Unpacking their historical context, we ponder the possibility of these rules being a divine test of faith and obedience. Plus, I'm taking this conversation from the religious realm to the practical world, discussing how these commandments could foster a more ethical workplace environment.

But trust me, this episode isn't all preachy. I shift gears to address the very real, harmful impacts of envy, especially when it prompts us to covet others' success. I’m diving deep into the dangerous repercussions such as manipulation, dishonesty, and the risk of losing sight of our own potential.  Lastly, I'll share some self-care strategies to help combat these feelings of envy. And, of course, I'll let you know how you can continue to support this podcast and help spread the message. So, are you ready to explore the commandments like you never have before? Tune in and join the conversation!

Transcript

Speaker 1: 0:04

Hey, welcome to the bartender's perspective. I'm so happy to have you here. Work is done for the day. Pull up a chair, have a seat, I'll pour you a drink, let's get started.

Speaker 1: 0:16

So in tonight's podcast, we're diving deep into a controversy surrounding the Ten Commandments. Are these ancient moral guidelines no more than just rules for us to follow, or are these moral principles and guidelines given to us in preparation later on for a test? Let's take a look. So to understand the controversy, we need to look back at a historical context. Ten Commandments are a foundational set of moral and religious principles. Since today is on, the Christianity believed to have been given to Moses on Mount Sinai Well, many of you as divine guidance. Let's look at an alternative perspective that these commandments were designed as a test challenging the faith and obedience of the people. And I want to acknowledge, before we move on, there are many other religions out there in the world that have their own guidelines and things for beliefs and moral principles, and I acknowledge that. But tonight I'm just speaking from the perspective of just this one, just so that we're clear for those of you who believe in different things.

Speaker 1: 1:31

But anyways, early on in that time, the Israelites ran wild and free. I mean, I would too if I'd been enslaved for 400 years. You probably want to stop and have a drink, socialize with that neighbor that didn't previously have time to visit as you were working on building kingdoms and anything else the Egyptians might have needed, I could tell you. I would also want to kick back too if I had crossed the sea that had been parted and I was stressing as to whether that wall of water was going to collapse on my way through. Maybe you see that giant shark from the movie the Megs swimming on the edge of the wall of that water, just ready to crash down on top of you. I mean, never mind the fact that there are mad Egyptians chasing after you know that want to kill you.

Speaker 1: 2:26

From my perspective, in that time, I do see the Ten Commandments as a set of rules and guidelines in Judaism, christianity, but in that sense it was clearly demonstrated. You know the guidance was needed and if you look at what happened while the stone tablets were being made and most of you know the story of the golden calf, but straight up, you know, these people got tired of waiting, they got bored and wanted something to worship and they made this golden calf started worshipping it and then they went crazy and started parting hearts, going wild in the camp, recklessly worshipping the false idols, you know, busting out the kegs, burning whatever. But what follows over these thousands of years? You know there's a developing message that can be seen in the Bible and in our world today. We have been given the information we needed for the exam and then the test began. So just for a moment, you know I'm not going to go all lecture lecture on you, but you know I do need to mention this.

Speaker 1: 3:33

You know, for context, there was a concept in psychology I studied it and many of the sciences called the testing hypothesis, you know, and it does raise intriguing questions where the commandments intentionally presented in a way that would require people to choose between following God's laws and succumbing to human desires. Some argue that facing these moral dilemmas, you know, was a way to gauge loyalty, devotion and the ability to make righteous choices, even when tempted. So take this real-world example of a testing hypothesis related to this concept, and the way I'm presenting it is in a non-quantitative way because, you know I want to keep this simple. I don't want to draw this out as this again, this in the lecture hall. But the hypothesis goes, observing the 10 commandments in a workplace will lead to a more ethical and harmonious work environment.

Speaker 1: 4:33

And the scenario you know that you work in a small office with colleagues from diverse backgrounds. You know you want to test that hypothesis. You know following the principles of the Ten Commandments can improve the workplace. So you decide to create a workplace experiment. You'll work for a month. You and your colleagues make a conscious effort to follow the ethical principles outline of the Ten Commandments. This means refraining from lying, stealing, showing respect to one another. You know data collection throughout the month. Then you collect qualitative data, anonymous surveys, you know, et cetera, asking questions like have you noticed any positive changes in the workplace? Do you feel more trust, respect among colleagues? And after that month-long experiment, you know you analyze the responses and results. You find that colleagues report feeling a greater sense, you know, of trust, reduce conflicts and Improve communication. You know during this period, hypothetically speaking. So a conclusion you know, based on this qualitative data and the feedback, you can conclude that following the principle, the Ten Commandments had a positive impact on the workplace environment, even though the results are expressed in quantitative numbers. You know this is a real-world, non quantitative example of a testing hypothesis, you know, as it relates, you know, to the Ten Commandments in a practical setting. So I just just wanted to point that out there For those of you who do like a little bit of science. But let's move on.

Speaker 1: 6:07

So the symbolic nature of the commandments you know, also fuels, you know, that, testing theory. Just to give you an example of two of the commandments you shall have no other gods before me To you shall not covet. You know, each commandment presents a unique challenge to human nature. But is this a deliberate design to see who would remain steadfast and who would falter? I can tell you right now the answer is yes and I will tell you why. You know we see this worshiping a false idol every day. You find it in an addiction where, rather than turn to a higher power for support, you find comfort in the bottle, that syringe and even that prostitute you find walking the street.

Speaker 1: 6:59

That false idol can also be seen in people who have to have power and control, deny any help or admonition that it might be wrong and get so lost in their pride and, for some, their pain, that they lose sight of humility and receiving the light of peace and letting go and surrendering, and but that doesn't make those people bad, you know wrong. It's part of the human experience to make mistakes, you know, and to fall down, you know we do so. When we take our first steps or ride our first bicycle, we fall down and we get back up and we keep going. There are many who endure, there are many who fall. You know who falter, but you know for the ones that endure. For a lot of them, you know it did come only after they faltered and it's, in the sense, our society today. You know the commandment you shall have no other gods before me as a guiding principle to remind us today the consequences Of our own doing and seeking out a false idol Rather than your higher power.

Speaker 1: 8:09

Do any of you have any false idols in your life currently that you are struggling with or trying to get past? That's a stronghold from the idol been established in your mind, something to think about you. And then we have. You shall not covet, you know. It essentially means you know you should not desire envy what belongs to someone else. So many of you have been in the past. You know you should not desire envy what belongs to someone else.

Speaker 1: 8:41

So many examples, I mean material possessions. If you admire your neighbor's car and wish it were yours, despite already having a car that serves you needs, you miss out on the experience and having an appreciation for the car that you do have. It might have 120,000 miles and not be as fancy as your neighbor's car. You know you're not doing a Tesla and it's all nice and flashy. But to do you think for a second that neighbor might be making a six a six hundred dollar a month car payment and be struggling to make those payments? Well, you have no car payment or that your car you currently own. Just a favorite thought.

Speaker 1: 9:21

You know a career success of some people coveting other colleagues jobs or positions instead of working towards their own career goals. You know they miss out on discovering more about themselves and the process. So let's say you know we have Bob. Bob has a bigger office across the way and his own parking spot, while John has a cubicle Across from him and still has to pay for parking at the farthest end of the lot each day. John doesn't make as much money as Bob, you know. But here's the distinction to think about. You know, john started in the mailroom of that office and eventually got promoted to the job he had based on his merits and hard work. Bob, who was looking, you know, to move up, and he saw a coworker that you know he was envious of the position he had and, rather than you know, tried to work towards his own career goals. Well, he did, but in a sense he coveted the other co-workers job. You know, he manipulated his way into that position by causing the person you know who was previously there to be terminated. He cheated and lied his way into that position in the process of hurting other people to get there. The test here was again, bob faltered and did what he had to do to covet that position. Well, john, rather than try to covet, endured the trek and worked his way up to that position.

Speaker 1: 10:59

Another is just a few examples. You know that there are many, many more. You know, for this podcast, this is just one man relationships as a tricky, tricky road, you know. Feeling envious of a friend's romantic relationship and desiring their partner, you know, rather than nurturing your own relationships I've seen this time and time again at the bar Men or women who have been happily married for many years but then, somewhere along the way, they sought solace in the arms of another and for a lot of them it all began from them spending time with single friends who talked about that one night stand they had, or introduced that new, fresh relationship. You know, and that married person might not be getting something at home and whatever form it might be, feeling something is lacking or they might begin to feel trapped in that marriage, seeing that Friends life and they're so envious, you know, rather than confront you know what the problems might be at home. They goes the easy route. You know. If you want to call it that and seek out a Relationship, I mean quote fingers from a one night stand, it might be a prostitute or it might be your neighbor's wife and any event, covening can be a very dangerous thing in relationships.

Speaker 1: 12:29

Financial status you know a lot of people wishing how you know they have the wealth or financial stability of someone else, even if you have enough to meet your own needs. I mean so my best friend, he used to deliver furniture for a furniture store company and he told me about this scheme that there are those out there that you know have enough to meet their own needs but they want to give off the persona that they have more so that they can fit in Into this well-to-do society. They'll go out and buy a really big, expensive house, but then I never furnish it. And what happens is when the weekend comes and they want to have a party, they'll order a bunch of furniture, pay for catering, have it all delivered, have it all set up, and then they have their well-to-do friends over who do actually have more than them. And when the party and everything's over, if they turn around and return all that furniture and everything, just to turn around and do it again a couple months later, and all the while these people wanting to have the wealth on the prestige of those other people. So in the process, I mean, it's not good to cover, cover it somebody else's wealth or financial stability. You know, if you want, try and be happy with what you have and if you're not, then go out and do something about it.

Speaker 1: 14:06

Physical appearance, you know, and being someone else's physical attributes or beauty Instead of being content with your own, you know it doesn't help. It doesn't help that the media puts a large amount of pressure On females, you know. For example, to meet a certain social and cultural standard Beauty, which can inevitably lead to poor body image and eating disorders. The more an individual is exposed to the Sun realistic standard, you know the more they find it is reflective of how they should look. You know, looking youthful and thin has become an essential part of what it means to be beautiful. By today's standards, you know, these standards are often unachievable, you know, especially for women. As women age and mature, you know this can lead to women feeling negative about their bodies and potentially experience more severe issues, such as Anxiety, depression, obsession with losing weight and, yeah, the greater likelihood of again developing an eating disorder and, lastly, coveting with someone else's talents, you know, or abilities, rather than developing your own skills. Yeah, it's gonna Not be a very healthy thing.

Speaker 1: 15:17

I had a gentleman and his best friend, you know, come to the bar years ago that wanted to become a doctor after seeing his best friend make it through medical school and he thought it sounded really cool when he you know the first surgery story his best friend had performed and he got it in his head for a time that he was going to go to medical school like his best friend. Then he applied and everything. But what little I knew of him, you know. He got anxious, really easy and stressful situations and thankfully, you know he found out before he went any further. You know that he was better suited, you know, to something with a lot less stress. I mean, come on y'all, if I had someone else's life in my hands, like literally, I would too. So but he later found, you know he was good at numbers. You know, in the very last time I talked to him not too long ago, you know, he was enjoying a very successful career in accounting.

Speaker 1: 16:18

So yeah, um, the commandment you shall not covet. You know it serves as a moral guideline to promote contentment and discourage jealousy and unhealthy desires. You know, for what others have. Do you have anything in your life today that you are coveting currently, or trying not to? You know, think about it.

Speaker 1: 16:44

So, with any historical debate, you know there's evidence. Evidence is key. Now, there's no definitive proof that the Ten Commandments were meant as a test. Certain stories and events, you know, in religious texts, you know, could be interpreted in this light. You know the story of Abraham, you know, being tested to sacrifice his son Isaac, you know was often cited as a precursor to the idea of divine trials. For those of you who are familiar with scripture from, you know the Gospel of Matthew. It says an example where the Pharisees, you know, leaders of the time, tested Jesus using the Ten Commandments. If you wanna reference the scripture, you can Matthew 19, 16 through 22,.

Speaker 1: 17:27

You know the young man, a rich man, who approached Jesus, you know, asking him what he must do to inherit eternal life. You know Jesus, you know, responded by, you know, telling him some of the commandments you should not murder, not commit adultery, you should not steal, not bear false witness, blah, blah, blah. The rich young man, you know, claimed to have kept all these commandments from his youth, you know. And then Jesus challenged him by saying you know, if you wanna be perfect, go, you know, sell your possessions, give to the poor and you'll have treasure in heaven. Then come and follow me. I mean, needless to say, the young man walked away. So let me ask you this, y'all if God asked you to give up everything you have ever worked for and just give it all away to follow him, could you do it? Yeah, take that one in. So this interaction demonstrated that the Ten Commandments were used as a test to reveal the young man's attachment to his wealth and his inability to fully follow Jesus' teachings. This highlights the deeper spiritual principles behind the commandments and the importance of love, selflessness and devotion to God.

Speaker 1: 18:43

In addition to following the rules, the controversy has deep philosophical and theological implications. The commandments were a test. What does this mean for our understanding of faith, obedience and the relationship between humans and the divine? What do you all think about this perspective? I mean, does it diminish the moral significance of the commandments or does it enhance it? If we were to consider the commandments as a test, we could draw parallels between this concept and the understanding of faith and obedience and the relationship between humans and the divine.

Speaker 1: 19:21

Imagine that Ten Commandments are viewed as a divine test of faith and obedience. In this scenario, adhering to commandments becomes a way for individuals to demonstrate their commitment to their faith and their willingness to obey the divine will. If religious students take tests to prove their knowledge and understanding of a subject, believers may view following the commandments as a way to demonstrate their understanding of, and alignment with, their religious teachings. So are any of you being tested today in your faith or what you believe? Think about that. This perspective on the commandments emphasizes the idea that faith and obedience are not passive concepts but active choices. By choosing to follow the commandments, individuals are actively participating in their faith and demonstrating their obedience to the divine. This relationship between humans and the divine becomes the dynamic, ongoing process of testing and reaffirming one's commitment to their faith. If you treat the commandments as a test and it can deepen your understanding of faith and obedience by highlighting the active role of individuals play in their relationship with the divine, you will continually strive to demonstrate your commitment through actions and adherence to moral guidelines. In this case, this perspective does indeed enhance the moral significance of the commandments. What conclusions can you draw from this perspective in your own life today? So lastly, beyond the historical, theological aspects, let's take a moment to discuss the modern relevance of this controversy. How might viewing the commandments as a test impact our interpretation of moral guidelines today? What do you think y'all? Can it offer a new perspective on the challenges we face in an increasingly complex world? I have a great example for you.

Speaker 1: 21:39

One modern controversy surrounding the Ten Commandments centers on their display in public spaces such as government buildings. Some argue that displaying them can be seen as a test of how we interpret moral guidelines in a diverse and secular society. So let's take a moment. This is not a real place. It's just an example. In a small town named Jonesville, there was a heated debate over whether to display the Ten Commandments in the town square. The town council proposed placing a large stone monument engraved with the commandments near the courthouse. Supporters argue that it would serve as a reminder of moral values and principles. However, not everyone in Jonesville agreed. A group of citizens led by Andrea believed that displaying the commandments in a public space violated the principles of the separation of church and state. They argued that it might make people of different faiths or non-religious backgrounds feel uncomfortable or excluded. As the controversy escalated, jonesville became divided. Public meetings were held and passionate arguments were made on both sides. Some argue that the commandments represented universal moral values, why others felt it was a religious imposition on a diverse community. The case forced society to grapple with the question of how to balance individual freedom of belief with the desire to promote moral values.

Speaker 1: 23:14

This is modern day, in a fictitious story, illustrates how the controversy surrounding the Ten Commandments can be seen as a test of how we interpret moral guidelines in a pluralistic society where diverse beliefs and values must coexist. It raises important questions about the role of religion in the public sphere and how we navigate moral and ethical issues in a modern context. So as I wrap up this episode, it's clear that the controversy surrounding the Ten Commandments as a test it's far from settled. As we've doubled into historical, religious and philosophical perspectives, it becomes clear that this ancient code of conduct holds different meanings for different people. For some, the idea of a divine test challenges their faith and raises questions about the nature of God's guidance. Others find in this interpretation a profound opportunity for personal growth and spiritual development. Whether you view the Ten Commandments as a moral compass, a divine test or something else entirely, what remains constant is their enduring impact on our world, shaping the way societies and individuals navigate the complex terrain of ethics, values and faith. Now, as you continue to explore these Ten Commandments principles seek not only answers but also a deeper understanding of the human quest for meaning, purpose and a shared sense of morality. The debates may persist, but it is through respectful dialogue and reflection that you can truly appreciate the significance of the Ten Commandments in your lives.

Speaker 1: 25:09

So, in closing, if you like my podcast, please feel free to tell at least three people about my podcast if you think they'll get something out of it. This will help me continue to get my message out there to more people. If you want to help me support the show, you can visit my website and leave me a tip on the tip chart. But unless you want to know the drink, as always. Thank you for stopping in. Here's your check. My regular podcast hours are, as always, every Sunday night at 7 pm, so you can come back and see me then. Have a great night.